PSL Rate Captaincy of Young Captains in PSL 2022

This thread is about PSL

PPakistani

Youngsta Beauty
Mar 11, 2021
173
107
84
Rate these guys. Who do you think has been the best Captain so far, not just his individual performance but tactical decisions as well.

Rizwan
Shadab
Shaheen
Babar

P.S. Its great to see Pak investing in young captains for a change so we are never short of captaincy material at international level.
 

PPakistani

Youngsta Beauty
Mar 11, 2021
173
107
84
Besides, i think they need to change captains for zalmi and gladiators as well.. maybe iftikhar and haider ? or fakhar zaman moving to zalmi and becoming captain
 
  • Like
Reactions: Prince Pathan

Choi Saab

Match Winner
Dec 9, 2020
20,471
8,864
4,004
Mohammed Rizwan - possibly has the best tactical nous out of the 4, you see him working with his players and commanding the field, there is a strategy for the batting, which is him and Masood build a base, allowing the likes of Maqsood, Tim David, Rossouw to express themselves and swing through. Yesterday despite a slow start, we saw how he took the lead and opened up the game with that Umaid Asif over to let him middle/lower order to express themselves. His use of Khushdil has been exemplary.

Shadab Khan - Easily the most dynamic and aggressive out of the four, his team is run on mindset which is integral to IU's success, there is a 'do or die' attitude which Shadab has identified as a way to allow his power hitters to express themselves without fear of consequences, reminds of Wasim Akram's story where IK told him to just bowl fast and not care about no balls. Not to mention he leads from the front and sets the tone for his team.

Shaheen Shah Afridi - (Natural bias) but he has been fantastic, it helps that as a bowler himself, he seems to be aware what each bowler requires and we see the way he himself has developed Zaman Khan (a newbie) on his own whilst on the playing field. Not sure his contribution to the batting strategy which is yet to be seen. But early signs are extremely encouraging.

Babar Azam - Difficult to judge, the squad is almost 95% Railu Kattas and I do believe even Ricky Ponting wouldn't be able to create anything here and unfortunately it seems Wasim Akram has more sway in decisions. There has been some captaincy flaws, such as S Farhan not batting in the right place, lack of use of Qasim Akram etc.

Overall, I'm excited that the main Pakistan squad consists of these guys as the core, they're all leadership material and compliment each other beautifully. Tactically you have Rizwan, Mindset you have Shadab and for the bowlers you have Shaheen and to lead the pack as Shaheen said, you have our own 'Ertugrul' in Babar Azam.
 

Mohsin

Jaadugar Spinner
IPL Draft Manager
Dec 9, 2020
10,781
2,571
1,725
Rizwan - A+
Shadab - A
Shaheen A-
Babar - bakwaas team/squad, what can he do.
 

Prince Pathan

Smooth Operator
IPL Draft Manager
Feb 19, 2021
5,226
1,162
870
Rizwan easily the best captain

Shadab is second on the list

Shaheen has been impressive in bursts too. Need to see more of him but he won't be a captain in domestic cricket as his captain is Rizwan with Ifti and Khalid Usman next on the list if Rizwan is unavailable

Shadab and Rizwan have always been the two best captains in domestic and it shows in the PSL too. They are both a perfect balance of defensive and aggressive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Patriot

Munna

Match Winner
IPL Draft Manager
Dec 7, 2020
21,875
8,682
4,700
Shaheen makes mistakes but that’s expected of any 21yo... even Fakhar Zaman pointed that out in a pre-match interview the other day. But he is improving and will continue to do so.

Problem for Zalmi and Gladiators is that they have not groomed any backup captains.

Zalmi’s core is based around players belonging to stone age... and then they are wasting guys like Haider. They could have made Hassan Ali as the future leader and face of their franchise but they were blinded in love of Darren Sammy.

Gladiators is all Sarfaraz. They need to start giving powers to Nawaz who is their main player. And also take care of Hasnain and Naseem who should be their future.
 

PakistanZ!

Tagra Khilari
Dec 9, 2020
10,409
4,333
2,017
Rizwan has been brilliant as expected

Shadab has also been great but been on the unlucky side a few times with injuries and losing won games

Shaheen impressive for his first season. Calm and collected

Babar can’t do much with the shite he’s dealing with. Few poor decisions in selection and batting order though
 

DeadlyVenom

Jaandar Opener
Sep 22, 2021
1,344
512
316
I have been very very impressed and pleasantly surprised by Shaheen Shah Afridi!

When his captaincy was announced I immediately wrote him off as being too hot-headed but he has been so cool and collected under pressure. He has also made some smart on-field decisions.

Rizwan is a Cheeta that goes without saying. He will be the skipper of Pakistans test team at some point in the future.

Shadab is a shrewd cricketer and should be put into position to lead the T20 team ASAP. In order to not hurt Babars feelings the PCB should say that Babar is being rested from T20 games and will only play occasionally so he can focus on the longer format. After the next T20 world cup our focus should be on the WTC anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bigboii

PakistanZ!

Tagra Khilari
Dec 9, 2020
10,409
4,333
2,017
Shadab is a shrewd cricketer and should be put into position to lead the T20 team ASAP. In order to not hurt Babars feelings the PCB should say that Babar is being rested from T20 games and will only play occasionally so he can focus on the longer format. After the next T20 world cup our focus should be on the WTC anyway.
What would the purpose of removing a performing captain who showed us results in his first assignment and all the team are happy to play for be?
 

DeadlyVenom

Jaandar Opener
Sep 22, 2021
1,344
512
316
What would the purpose of removing a performing captain who showed us results in his first assignment and all the team are happy to play for be?
We need some sizzle and spice to keep forums active.

In all seriousness though, the WT20 wasn't a success. We played well but should have won it.

Our real focus should be on cultivating a successful test legacy because that's how great sides are measured. Give someone else the pressure of T20 captaincy so Babar can take a rest occasionally and focus on the longer formats. He is still an integral part of the squad but should be rested for irrelevant series and matches in T20.
 

PakistanZ!

Tagra Khilari
Dec 9, 2020
10,409
4,333
2,017
We need some sizzle and spice to keep forums active.

In all seriousness though, the WT20 wasn't a success. We played well but should have won it.

Our real focus should be on cultivating a successful test legacy because that's how great sides are measured. Give someone else the pressure of T20 captaincy so Babar can take a rest occasionally and focus on the longer formats. He is still an integral part of the squad but should be rested for irrelevant series and matches in T20.
Losing the World Cup wasn’t on Babar though, even that Aus game should have been won after Fakhar and then Shadab’s efforts. Just lost it at the worst moment in the death.

While Babar is performing with the bat and captains responsibility it’s unfair to remove him. Pakistan have improved under him and are moving in the right direction finally. No need to change what’s being fixed
 
  • Like
Reactions: Square Drive

Patriot

Pasli Torh Bowler
Dec 9, 2020
15,558
3,486
2,524
finna start some heated debate and throw in Dahani name to captain Pakistan in International level
 

Prince Pathan

Smooth Operator
IPL Draft Manager
Feb 19, 2021
5,226
1,162
870
I have been very very impressed and pleasantly surprised by Shaheen Shah Afridi!

When his captaincy was announced I immediately wrote him off as being too hot-headed but he has been so cool and collected under pressure. He has also made some smart on-field decisions.

Rizwan is a Cheeta that goes without saying. He will be the skipper of Pakistans test team at some point in the future.

Shadab is a shrewd cricketer and should be put into position to lead the T20 team ASAP. In order to not hurt Babars feelings the PCB should say that Babar is being rested from T20 games and will only play occasionally so he can focus on the longer format. After the next T20 world cup our focus should be on the WTC anyway.
Rizwan would be further ahead than Shadab for the T20 captaincy if it came down to it. He's just made it to his 4th consecutive final as captain

2 with Khyber and 2 with Multan. His win percentage in that is unbelievable.

However if it means causing a disturbance in the Pak team and people turning needlessly on Rizwan it is best to be avoided. His time will come eventually. No need to force it but the fact remains that tactically he is the best captain hands down in Pakistan.
 

DeadlyVenom

Jaandar Opener
Sep 22, 2021
1,344
512
316
Rizwan would be further ahead than Shadab for the T20 captaincy if it came down to it. He's just made it to his 4th consecutive final as captain

2 with Khyber and 2 with Multan. His win percentage in that is unbelievable.

However if it means causing a disturbance in the Pak team and people turning needlessly on Rizwan it is best to be avoided. His time will come eventually. No need to force it but the fact remains that tactically he is the best captain hands down in Pakistan.
Rizwan is an all format player and will never be rested. T20 captaincy at this stage is too much of a burden IMO as he shouldn't play all T20 matches. He is a diamond player and should be kept in peak condition for big games that matter, no need to play him against Zimbabwe, Bangladesh etc in every t20 match.

He will be Pak test captain soon.
 

Cani

Smooth Operator
Apr 5, 2021
4,594
1,754
912
Shaheed and Shadab have been real breaths of fresh air. Great to see such leadership
 

Inswinger

Dalair Batsman
Dec 9, 2020
5,934
3,319
1,363
Rizwan is an all format player and will never be rested. T20 captaincy at this stage is too much of a burden IMO as he shouldn't play all T20 matches. He is a diamond player and should be kept in peak condition for big games that matter, no need to play him against Zimbabwe, Bangladesh etc in every t20 match.

He will be Pak test captain soon.
Rizwan being Test captain soon means Babar has failed. What has indicated that give Babar’s performance as Pakistan’s captain?
 

DeadlyVenom

Jaandar Opener
Sep 22, 2021
1,344
512
316
Rizwan being Test captain soon means Babar has failed. What has indicated that give Babar’s performance as Pakistan’s captain?
He doesn't necessarily have to have failed.

If there is a better person for the job then the captaincy should change. By soon I mean 2-3 years not tomorrow.

Babar has not performed with the bat in test match cricket and has generally so far captained against weak opposition. The Australia tour is a massive opportunity for him to stamp his authority on the side both with the bat and with the captaincy. All eyes will be on this tour and inshAllah he will succeed.

But If he doesn't succeed in this test cycle and we just do OK - then it would make sense to let him concentrate with the bat and someone else to take the burden of captinacy.
 

Patriot

Pasli Torh Bowler
Dec 9, 2020
15,558
3,486
2,524
He doesn't necessarily have to have failed.

If there is a better person for the job then the captaincy should change. By soon I mean 2-3 years not tomorrow.

Babar has not performed with the bat in test match cricket and has generally so far captained against weak opposition. The Australia tour is a massive opportunity for him to stamp his authority on the side both with the bat and with the captaincy. All eyes will be on this tour and inshAllah he will succeed.

But If he doesn't succeed in this test cycle and we just do OK - then it would make sense to let him concentrate with the bat and someone else to take the burden of captinacy.

I would suggest go check Rizwan Intl. captaincy record.
 

Prince Pathan

Smooth Operator
IPL Draft Manager
Feb 19, 2021
5,226
1,162
870
Rizwan still the best mind in Pak but thoroughly impressed by Shaheen.

Khyber have trophy winners in Khalid Usman, Rizwan, Iftikhar and now Shaheen. Makes sense why they win everything. That same type of mentality is coming to the national team too.

With Rizwan, Shadab and now Shaheen able to guide Babar. Exciting times ahead
 

Fireworks11

Pasli Torh Bowler
IPL Draft Manager
Dec 9, 2020
16,584
3,508
2,595
Shaheen made a huge statement with this performance. Led from the front. Top notch.
 

DeadlyVenom

Jaandar Opener
Sep 22, 2021
1,344
512
316
Rizwan still the best mind in Pak but thoroughly impressed by Shaheen.

Khyber have trophy winners in Khalid Usman, Rizwan, Iftikhar and now Shaheen. Makes sense why they win everything. That same type of mentality is coming to the national team too.

With Rizwan, Shadab and now Shaheen able to guide Babar. Exciting times ahead
KPK is the backbone of Pak cricket.

That region is a real talent factory and the talent is allowed to flourish because there isn't as much nepotism in selection.

Its the most meritocratic cricket region in Pakistan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Prince Pathan

Prince Pathan

Smooth Operator
IPL Draft Manager
Feb 19, 2021
5,226
1,162
870
KPK is the backbone of Pak cricket.

That region is a real talent factory and the talent is allowed to flourish because there isn't as much nepotism in selection.

Its the most meritocratic cricket region in Pakistan.
Abdul Rehman Khan is to thank foe this. Wherever the man goes the results and talent follows. He even managed to get South Punjab to the finals the previous year but lost against the monster he had built in the final.
 

Live Scores